Context-Driven Decisions: The Impact of Framed Information on Financial Choices

Abstract

This paper examines how contextual framing influences financial decision-making under uncertainty. Poor decision-making is pervasive in financial behavior, and one proposed remedy is choice architecture, which seeks to improve decisions by altering the framing of information or decision tasks. In this context, we investigate how contextual information about a firm’s prospects affects investment choices, even when the distribution of outcomes is explicitly provided. In an online experiment, participants were randomly assigned to a control or treatment group and presented with decision-making tasks. Qualitative details about a firm's prospects significantly altered choices. Positive contextual framing increased the likelihood of retaining a stock, while negative framing reduced it, despite unchanged objective probabilities. In contrast, alternative exercises without specific contextual details showed no significant effects. These findings highlight how the design and contextual relevance of framing influence decision-making under uncertainty, offering insights into the role of qualitative information in financial behavior and choice architecture.